Fishhooks in emissions trading review

Published: Wed 31 Oct 2007 01:02 PM
31 October 2007
Fishhooks in emissions trading review - Business NZ
A review by the International Energy Agency of New Zealand's proposed emissions trading scheme is not the glowing endorsement it appears to be, says Business NZ.
While it is being promoted as "praise" and a "positive review", there are in fact two big fishhooks in the review, says Business NZ energy analyst George Riddell.
"The first is the impact of 'hot air' credits on the price of carbon, making it much higher than the Government estimates. A higher than estimated price for carbon will mean a more negative economic impact on all New Zealanders than has so far been acknowledged.*
"The second relates to timing. The IEA's analysis was of the NZ Government's Framework Document which contains no information on the proposed timetable for implementation. The IAE correspondence indicates an assumption that our trading system will be developed over a period of years instead of only a few months. Business NZ would be interested to hear the IEA's view on the actual timeframe being adopted by the NZ Government.
"With those two caveats, the IEA's review is far less rosy than New Zealand would wish.
"We agree there are opportunities from a less carbon intense future and business has been in support of carbon trading for some time but the risks from a rushed introduction are major. More care and time are needed to get a workable system," Mr Riddell said.
*So-called 'hot air' credits are the credits that were allocated to Russia and the Ukraine for industries that have since collapsed, destroying the value attached to the credits. 'Hot air' credits are not accepted in the European trading system, with which New Zealand will seek to be integrated. It is the trading of the 'hot air' that the NZ Government and officials have indicated will keep the price of carbon low in the NZ market. Losing this opportunity would see New Zealand facing a much higher price than estimated by the Government.

Next in New Zealand politics

Speech From The Throne
By: New Zealand Government
Law Commission Recommends New DNA Laws For Criminal Investigations
By: Law Commission
New Zealand Government To Declare A Climate Emergency
By: New Zealand Government
Crown Accounts Reflect Govt’s Careful Economic Management
By: New Zealand Government
Green Party Announce Portfolio Reshuffle With Talented And Energised Caucus Team
By: Green Party
NZ Govt Considers Making House Prices Part Of RBNZ Mandate
By: XE Money Transfer
Green Party Respond To Government Review Of Housing Settings
By: Green Party
Rewriting The Rulebook On DNA In Criminal Investigations – Expert Reaction
By: Science Media Centre
Government To Consider Recommendations On DNA Use In Criminal Investigations
By: New Zealand Government
Climate Change An Economic Issue; Critical For The Planet’s Future
By: Make Lemonade
Climate Emergency Declaration A Win But Needs Action
By: Greenpeace New Zealand
Declaration Of ‘Symbolic’ Climate Emergency
By: Extinction Rebellion
Minimum Wage Hike Isn’t What The Economy Needs
By: New Zealand National Party
Why Not $50 An Hour?
By: ACT New Zealand
Greens Commit To Ensuring Strong Oceans Protection This Term
By: Green Party
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILE © Scoop Media