Judith Collins MP
National Party Pacific Island Affairs Spokeswoman
20 February 2007
Pacific Island parents concerned about smacking ban
National Party Pacific Island Affairs spokeswoman Judith Collins says Helen Clark should prepare for a backlash from the
Pacific Islands community given her support for a smacking ban.
"From the conversations I have had with the Pacific community, it's clear they fear the anti-smacking legislation will
further disempower them.
"Pacific families are traditionally very strong and functioning. Pacific children comprise only 6% of Child Youth and
Family cases, yet parental discipline is practised by many Pacific families."
"No political party supports serious violence against children, but nor should we back a law change that potentially
makes criminals out of otherwise responsible parents.
"The supporters of this legislation claim police will exercise discretion when deciding whether to prosecute. I'm not
convinced that the Pacific community takes any comfort from that sort of assurance."