Hon Lockwood Smith
National Party Immigration Spokesman
06 December 2006
PM's office denies Ingram Inquiry crucial evidence
Labour's refusal to pay for legal advice for the original Taito Phillip Field whistleblower has ensured the Ingram
Inquiry missed out on crucial evidence, says National's Immigration spokesman, Lockwood Smith.
"It also probably meant the inquiry took longer and cost more money becasue other witnesses clearly provided information
designed to confuse the Inquiry.
"Dr Noel Ingram, QC, approached the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet in December 2005 asking the Crown to pay
for legal costs for key witness Keith Williams. Mr Williams had requested legal advice before giving evidence.
"The Prime Minister said in the House on 30 August that Dr Ingram did not raise the issue with her office.
"Recently it was reported that DPMC Chief Executive Maarten Wevers confirmed that Dr Ingram took a request to him and he
turned it down. What's startling about that revelation is that Mr Wevers knew at the time that Mr Williams would not
give evidence to the Inquiry without legal advice.
"How is it that the Prime Minister does not know what is going on her own office?
"It's incredible to think that the only person other than Maxine Field, who knew of the secret deal between Taito
Phillip Field and Sunan Siriwan, was denied legal protection and did not give evidence."
ENDS