Hon Tony Ryall
National Party Health Spokesman
15 November 2006
Hodgson should tell truth about primary care strategy
Health Minister Pete Hodgson’s praise for a Commonwealth Fund survey today stands in stark contrast to his own advice to
Cabinet criticising the slow progress of the Government’s primary health care strategy, says National’s Health
spokesman, Tony Ryall.
“Mr Hodgson should tell the full story of the Commonwealth Fund survey, and actually focus on important issues for the
future of primary care. The survey is about process, not outcomes.
“New Zealand is falling behind in the areas that the Government’s primary health care strategy was supposed to fix.
“The survey shows that New Zealand practices, compared to those in other countries, feel they are less well prepared to
provide optimum care for patients with multiple chronic diseases and mental health problems.
“Patients will also laugh at Mr Hodgson’s claim that New Zealand is top for after-hours care, when problems with
after-hours care are occurring throughout the country.
“The survey also showed 85% of New Zealand doctors reported long waiting times for elective surgery or hospital care –
by far the worst view of any of the seven countries surveyed.
“The report says that ‘based on doctors reports, long waits for elective surgery appear to be the norm in New Zealand’.
“Mr Hodgson should admit that the Government’s primary health care strategy has failed to meet its own goals in a number
of key areas.”
The Minister told Cabinet in April that ‘progress toward the PHCS’s aim of improved coordination across service areas
has so far been limited… coordination between primary care and hospital[s] is still weak…progress towards…a well
developed multidisciplinary workforce is so far limited to a small number of PHOs’.
“Mr Hodgson spends too much time on peripheral issues. He should focus more on the pressing issue of improving quality
and patient outcomes,” says Mr Ryall.
ENDS