ACT's The Letter – 19 December 2005
Liberty is safe as parliament is adjourned for the summer. Peters loses his electoral petition. The Herald poll puts
All I want to be is MP for…
Peters lost his electoral petition but it was close. Clarkson believed he had just $10,000 of reportable expenditure.
The court ruled he had spent $18,500, just $1,500 from the limit. The court ruled that 25% of the cost of an
advertisement run by the local paper was an electoral expense. If it had said it all must count or even 60% Clarkson
would have been out. With 10 days to go Peters warned Clarkson he would challenge his expenses - so he stopped all
The one article of faith the NZ First caucus has is in the infallibility of their leader. The MPs are even more
shattered than Winston. They all know that without the safety net of an electorate, the party would have been gone after
their last time in government. We think Winston looked unwell during the election, fought a bad campaign, made a serious
mistake taking the Foreign Affairs Ministry and has now lost a court case, which had he said nothing, he would have won.
Maybe that lifestyle is catching up with him.
Bad news for Labour
Peters knows that no third party in coalition has made the 5% threshold in the next election. His incentive is to leave
the government before the election. Labour has only governed in a booming economy reinforced by a good lead in the
polls. The last time an MMP coalition faced a difficult economy and poor polls was Jim Bolger during the Asian crisis
and his coalition collapsed. It is doubtful that MMP minority governments can survive an economic downturn. The moment
the Clark government seems in trouble, Peters and Dunne will be the first to the life rafts.
A massive 65% of readers think the Reserve Bank will raise interest rates again in January. Our predictive polls have a
good record for accuracy. We are not so sure. There is clear evidence the economy is slowing. The US Federal Reserve has
signaled that its interest rate rises will stop and the fall in oil prices is easing inflationary pressure.
TVNZ says National are 9% ahead, the Herald says Labour ended the year slightly ahead. As TVNZ said National would win
the election and the Herald picked Labour, the paper is more likely to be correct. Telephone polls are no longer
accurate. Too many people just have cell phones.
Labour is pleased with the way the session ended. The government managed to get its significant promises either
legislated, (student loans interest free and working for families) or introduced, (waka jumping bill). Peter Dunne who
opposed the original legislation voted in favour. Despite being a minority the government did not lose a vote.
It is all done
The government's program for next year is for parliament to resume on 14 February and meet for just 30 weeks, nearly a
month less than usual.
Prior to the election Labour Ministers were exposed to a crossfire from National and ACT and on the days that Peters was
anti Labour, shots from NZ First. Ministers have found it much easier to answer predictable National questions than the
questions out of right field from ACT and out of anywhere from NZ First.
Before the election Don Brash was criticised for never being in parliament. When Brash has been in parliament he has
failed to take the lead on any issue. The media has decided that he is an interim leader and the real interest is the
contest between John Key and Bill English.
It is no contest
Build English up as they will, it is no contest. The public has decided already that it is Key. He is not ready but then
neither was Brash.
Final Maiden Speeches out of 10
*David Bennett, National Hamilton East (4) National's youngest MP at 35. Spoilt by the Academy award list of thanks,
learning his younger brother is a lawyer was too much information. But the speech shows promise.
*Dr Jackie Blue, National list (5) the country's first breast physician and another of National's influx of doctors.
"The public health sector, despite having billions of dollars poured into it, has become bloated, overly bureaucratic
and bogged down with ever expanding waiting lists." Frustration at the failures of the health system has seen an
unprecedented number of doctors stand for parliament.
Eric Roy, who won Invercargill, came up with a new way to campaign. Just as the decline in religion has led to the new
occupation, marriage celebrant, the local funeral director approached him asking if he would conduct funerals. In the 18
months before the election Eric was speaking to up to three hundred people a week who in their grief were vulnerable to
Happy Christmas and New Year
Like politics we too take a break until late January.
Here is a number of interesting Internet sites for summer reading. For news, www.economist.com http://www.economist.com/
www.rodneyhide.com http://www.rodneyhide.com/ http://stuff.co.nz http://stuff.co.nz/ - read the nations newspapers.
Then for fun www.en.wikipedia.org http://www.en.wikipedia.org/ the online encyclopedia, which you can help, edit, grow
and maintain. www.imdb.com http://www.imdb.com/ database of old and new movies, includes the top 250 films of all time
as voted by website visitors. www.trademe.co.nz http://www.trademe.co.nz/ NZ's most visited website that is transforming
the country into a single market.
You can buy or sell anything from a Winston squeaky dog to earthmoving equipment, a must visit. www.gutenberg.org
http://www.gutenberg.org/ -7,000 classic books, free to download from Sun Tzu to Edgar Allen Poe www.politicos.co.uk
http://www.politicos.co.uk/ - books on politics, public policy and political philosophy. The widest range on the net and
enough to keep you going until we return.