INDEPENDENT NEWS

Race Policy Review Prevarication

Published: Fri 26 Mar 2004 12:12 AM
Race Policy Review Prevarication
ACT New Zealand Maori Affairs Spokesman Stephen Franks today described Labour's terms of reference, for its review of race-based policy, as prevarication.
"Pages of waffle to set up a unit, `co-ordination', `identifying criteria', `evaluating', `reviewing', `monitoring', `planning', `advising', `establishing schedules', `maintaining overviews' and `developing guidelines' is not doing. They are excuses for not doing," Mr Franks said.
"This simple job could be done overnight with genuine will. Labour could simply declare an end to race discrimination and instruct public servants to act accordingly. That's far less mysterious and confusing than the instructions that started this race discrimination.
"Any complexity is self-created, to hide the logic vacuum at the heart of the race privilege industry. It's complicated because it's dishonest - many words trying to deceive. Many perpetrators are well meaning - it's complicated because they've been trying to deceive themselves, along with everyone else.
"When they instructed race consciousness across the community, they didn't bother with definitions, criteria and outcome reviews. They ordered thousands of decent people, in hundreds of organisations, to obey Treaty principles no one had ever seen, and which were never defined. They didn't exist then, and don't now. It was the same with decrees to act in accordance with the fake partnership. Officials were told to pretend a partnership had existed for generations.
"Labour didn't use a `unit' to work out outcomes for other cultural engineering projects. Years ago, Margaret Wilson effectively married over 200,000 de facto couples, for property sharing, and revoked the wills of thousands of elderly. She didn't bother with consultation.
"If Mr Mallard unwound official racism overnight, thousands of public servants in central and local government would breathe a huge sigh of relief. They'd go back to dealing with people on merit. `Cultural safety' would stop being an exemption pass from the thought police, and return to being good manners. We'd all be delighted to watch the cultural consultants, advisers, and commissars packing their bags to find genuinely useful employment.
"The terms of reference pretend responsiveness to New Zealanders who've had enough of racism without risking a meltdown with Labour's Treaty sponsors.
"If Mr Mallard had used his customary pithiness, the terms of reference would have said `look busy, write lots of long words, make it very complicated, drag it out until after the next election, threatening as few of our sacred cows as you can, and then we will think of something new'," Mr Franks said.

Next in New Zealand politics

Gordon Campbell on the GCSB’s security hang-up with Russia
By: Gordon Campbell
Prime Minister to attend CHOGM
By: New Zealand Government
Approval for Inquiry into Operation Burnham
By: New Zealand Government
No new permits for offshore exploration
By: New Zealand Government
Summit identifies actions to improve road safety
By: New Zealand Government
Science Deadline - This Week in Sci-Tech
By: Science Media Centre NZ
NZ 'prevented harm being done' by state-backed hacks - PM
By: RNZ
Minister surprised journalist included in reference group
By: RNZ
Cracking the Enigma Code (of NZ foreign policy)
By: RNZ
IGIS must explain legal basis for reference group
By: New Zealand National Party
Inspector-General has serious questions to answer
By: New Zealand National Party
Speech: Refresh puts spotlight on cyber security
By: New Zealand Government
Govt considers naming-and-shaming state sponsored cybercrime
By: BusinessDesk
Nukes to cyber war – NZ security in focus
By: Massey University
Gordon Campbell on Winston Peters' cozying up to Trump
By: Gordon Campbell
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media