Minister Chooses Savings Over Humanity
Tuesday 21 Oct 2003 Heather Roy Press Releases -- Health
ACT New Zealand Health Spokesman Heather Roy today challenged the Minister of Health to take the advice of health
experts and address the real problems caused by patients waiting indefinitely for treatment.
"Labour fails to acknowledge the true cost for patients who have been removed from waiting lists despite the fact
clinicians have said they require surgery or further treatment, endure pain, suffering and depression, and frequently
cost the taxpayer more than they would have if treated promptly.
"The study by orthopaedic trainee Dr David Ardern has highlighted the serious consequences for Taranaki orthopaedic
patients but the problem is occurring throughout New Zealand and in all specialty areas," said Mrs Roy.
"Health Minister Annette King must act to address this problem which for the first time has been quantified. Although
the Minister is known to place financial considerations above the pain and suffering of patients,
this study shows that it would be cheaper to operate on these patients. "The Minister can no longer ignore what doctors
and others working in the medical field have been telling her for a long time. She must accept that doctors who are
responsible for treating people are the ones to make the decisions about where precious health dollars are best used,
not the bean counters at her Ministry.
"Ideology is preventing this government from exploring acceptable alternatives. The private hospitals are
under-utilised and the Ministry of Health discourages innovation of individual hospital departments. The solution is in
emphasising the treatment of patients rather than making decisions based on bean counting
"New Zealand's Soviet-style health system is not working. But for the dedication of our health professionals the system
would collapse completely," Mrs Roy said.
ENDS
For more information visit ACT online at http://www.act.org.nz or contact the ACT Parliamentary Office at
act@parliament.govt.nz.