Sentence Shaves Scandalous
"Today's reduction of the sentences of Bruce Howse - convicted of murdering his step-daughters Saliel and Olympia - and
RSA triple murderer William Dwane Bell are Sentencing Act failures," ACT New Zealand Justice Spokesman Stephen Franks
said today.
"Both were sentenced to life imprisonment. As everyone knows, criminals serve only the non-parole period of their
so-called life sentence," Mr Franks said.
"For more than a year, Justice Minister Phil Goff has admitted problems with his law, but the Government refuses to
timetable a repair - even after the Court of Appeal last week pleaded with Parliament for reform.
"In the Howse case, the Sentencing Act's conflicting instructions have forced the Court of Appeal to tinker with
sentences handed down by a Judge who heard all the evidence. In response to Howse's lawyer's complaint that 28 years
left Howse with `no hope for the future', the Court pointed out that Howse's crime left Saliel and Olympia with no
future at all.
"But they then have to note that the Sentencing Act meant they `must impose the least restrictive outcome that is
appropriate in the circumstances'.
"Judges must be given the power to fix sentences that do justice and, in these cases, make life mean life. The law
should also change to discourage legally aided appeals, which offer no downside for the criminals, but multiply the
misery of the victims.
"Sentences should only be reduced when there is obvious gross injustice. Shaving three years off the sentences of two
murderers is tinkering, and offers cruel insult to the victims," Mr Franks said.