Bioethics Council likely to be talkfest
The jury will be out for a while yet on whether the new Bioethics Council will be anything more than a place for
interesting philosophical debate, Green Party Co-Leader Jeanette Fitzsimons said today.
The Government today announced the membership of Toi te Taiao: The Bioethics Council, which was recommended by the Royal
Commission on Genetic Modification. Environment Minister Marian Hobbs said the advisory body would be charged with
enhancing New Zealand's understanding of the cultural, ethical and spiritual aspects of biotechnology, and ensuring that
the values held by New Zealanders were considered in its use.
Ms Fitzsimons said: "While I have nothing against the people appointed to the Bioethics Council, and I am sure they have
New Zealand's best interests at heart, the fact is that the Government has not given them any role in decision-making.
The Government wants them only to draw attention to future developments we might not have thought about yet.
"New Zealanders are feeling very disillusioned that the hundreds of thousands of people - who made submissions to the
Royal Commission, or sent postcards asking for genetic engineering to be confined to the laboratory, or marched twice in
Auckland against the release of GE - have been ignored."
"The Government has shown itself determined to proceed regardless of the will of the people, and ERMA (the Environmental
Risk Management Authority) has approved projects contrary to the advice of its own Maori advisory committee, set up
under its Act to consider Maori cultural and ethical values," Ms Fitzsimons said.
"I wish the new council well. But I will be surprised if New Zealanders feel it is worthwhile engaging with."