INDEPENDENT NEWS

Individual super accounts a backward step - Greens

Published: Mon 18 Jun 2001 04:57 PM
18 June 2001
Individual super accounts a backward step - Greens
The Green Party says any move towards individualised super accounts would undermine the fair and egalitarian superannuation scheme which Labour and the Alliance claim to stand by.
The Government announced today that they had reached an agreement with Winston Peters which would allow future governments to convert the scheme to individualised accounts.
"I am really disappointed that Dr Cullen is prepared to accommodate Mr Peters' fixation, when any move to split the fund into individual accounts undermines the very heart of our superannuation system," said Green Party co-leader Rod Donald.
"Individualised accounts are deceitful, expensive and discriminatory."
Mr Donald said individual accounts are not only much more expensive to administer, they also deceive taxpayers into thinking that they own the money in their account, when in fact it has come out of the general tax pool.
"In the final analysis, the only practical reason for having individual accounts is so the Government can pay differing amounts to individuals in different circumstances.
"Many people, whether because they are full-time parents, or because they are paid less as a female or unskilled worker, or because they work fewer hours in their lives due to poor health or unemployment, will contribute less during their lives as a taxpayer.
"An individualised super scheme would punish these people for what is no fault of their own, and would reintroduce high levels of poverty for older people."
Analysis of the Peters Retirement Savings Scheme in 1997 showed that under his proposal, only 10-15 percent of women (and one percent of Maori women) would save enough to be assured of a pension at the current level. 92 percent of the public rejected Peters' scheme in 1997.
"Labour and the Alliance are setting the whole superannuation scheme up for a huge fall by agreeing to make it easier to individualise the fund," said Mr Donald. "Trading off future universality for this year's political support for the fund is too big a price to pay."
ENDS

Next in New Zealand politics

Gordon Campbell on what’s wrong with Wellington
By: Gordon Campbell
$1m Compensation To Christchurch Gun Owners In First Event
By: RNZ
Youth Parliament 2019 Event Kicks Off in the Capital
By: New Zealand Government
Foreign Minister to visit United States of America
By: New Zealand Government
Gordon Campbell on the Aussie banks’ latest fee hike excuse
By: Gordon Campbell
Terms of Reference for Defence Estate Review Released
By: New Zealand Government
Race Relations Commissioner appointed
By: New Zealand Government
Students granted formal qualifications after fees scrapped
By: New Zealand Government
Million-dollar start to gun collection events
By: Ministry of Education
Praise after first firearms collection event
By: New Zealand Government
Cantabrians hand in 542 firearms in one weekend
By: New Zealand Police
First Firearms collection event a success
By: New Zealand Police
Firearms collection event update – Thank you Canterbury
By: New Zealand Police
Gun 'buyback' pure political theatre
By: ACT New Zealand
NZ to learn from US gun violence report
By: Amnesty International
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media