INDEPENDENT NEWS

Court Decision Raises Fresh Questions

Published: Fri 14 Jul 2000 09:13 AM
Court Decision Raises Fresh Questions Over Driver's Licence Review
14 July 2000
COURT DECISION RAISES FRESH QUESTIONS OVER DRIVER'S LICENCE REVIEW
United New Zealand leader, Hon Peter Dunne, says the District Court's decision in the case of former Alliance press secretary, Moana Sinclair, raises fresh questions about the Government's review of the driver's licence system.
Mr Dunne has previously criticised the Government's review as too narrow and ill-timed, and says the Sinclair decision proves him right on both counts.
"It shows that the Government rushed into a narrowly focussed review before relevant Court rulings like the Sinclair verdict were available."
"This ruling - that even though she did not have a photographic licence Ms Sinclair was not an unlicensed driver - goes to the heart of much of the concern about the new system."
"Many people who have philosophical objections to carrying a digitised photographic licence have not upgraded their old lifetime licences and have been wondering about their legal position as a consequence."
"This ruling implies that although they may not have a new licence, they cannot be regarded as unlicensed drivers."
"Where does this leave other drivers - such as older people who have not passed their new licence test?"
"Are they now to be seen in the same light as Ms Sinclair?" Mr Dunne asks.
Mr Dunne says this is a serious issue the Government's review needs to address.
"Otherwise, this review will become a meaningless mockery of how to make the system work better, while the Courts are in effect saying that it does not matter, because the old lifetime licence means someone is still a licensed driver, even if they do not have the new photographic licence."
"This is nothing short of farce," he says.
ENDS

Next in New Zealand politics

One-stop Shop Major Projects On The Fast Track
By: New Zealand Government
GPS 2024: Over $20 Billion To Get Transport Back On Track
By: New Zealand Government
New Zealand Provides Further Humanitarian Support To Gaza And The West Bank
By: New Zealand Government
High Court Judge Appointed
By: New Zealand Government
Lobbyists Riding Shotgun With Coalition Government
By: New Zealand Labour Party
Say Hello To NZ’s Most Anti-environment Government In Decades
By: Green Party
Fast Track Is Outright Assault On Environment
By: Forest And Bird
Coalition Sticking Plasters Over New Zealand’s Infrastructure Crisis
By: New Zealand Taxpayers' Union
A Fast Track To A More Sure-footed Future
By: Infrastructure NZ
GPS 2024: New $500 Million Pothole Prevention Fund
By: New Zealand Government
GPS 2024: 15 New Roads Of National Significance
By: New Zealand Government
GPS 2024: Keeping New Zealanders Safer On Our Roads
By: New Zealand Government
GPS 2024: Investing In Reliable Public Transport
By: New Zealand Government
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILE © Scoop Media