9 March 2000
WHY SHOULD SAVERS PAY TWICE FOR SUPERANNUATION?
United New Zealand leader, Hon Peter Dunne, says the Finance Minister’s proposed dedicated fund for future New Zealand
superannuation is a disincentive to private savings.
“People who are saving now for their retirement will resent having the Government put aside another portion of their
taxes to provide future superannuation for those who have not been so prudent.”
“Why should today’s savers pay twice?” Mr Dunne asks.
Mr Dunne says Dr Cullen’s socialisation of superannuation makes the re-introduction of tax breaks for savings
contributions virtually inevitable.
It also highlights how poorly thought out the current strategy is.
“At the moment, all Dr Cullen can do is muse about the possibility of a dedicated fund, and wonder publicly about the
sustainability of the current TTE (Tax/Tax/Exempt) regime for superannuation schemes, but he has no concrete plans to
deal with the issue.”
“What is certain is that he is trading off the prospect of any future tax cuts for the saving generation against
pre-funding everyone else’s superannuation.”
“Unless he protects the position of today’s savers, all he will have done is replace the current politically
unsustainable superannuation arrangements with a new set of politically unsustainable arrangements.”
“Having better off New Zealanders pay for their own superannuation and everyone else’s besides might suit Labour’s and
the Alliance’s political agenda, but it will not resolve the problem.”
“All Dr Cullen is doing is adding more confusion and uncertainty to an area already rife with both,” Mr Dunne says.
ENDS
New Zealand’s Liberal Party
MEDIA STATEMENT
HON PETER DUNNE, MP
LEADER UNITED NEW ZEALAND
Parliament Buildings, Wellington 1.
h (04)471 9410 or (025) 469 808. Fax (04)499 7266.
e-mail: peter.dunne@parliament.govt.nz. Internet Address: http://www.united.org.nz
New Zealand’s Liberal Party