Ministers, Corrections at odds on Waikeria prison contract

Published: Wed 11 Jul 2018 11:03 AM
Ministers and Corrections at odds on Waikeria prison contract
Jane Patterson, Political Editor
The head of Corrections has contradicted statements made by senior government ministers in Parliament, that a contract for the public private partnership (PPP) to build the new Waikeria Prison was already in place when the government came to power.
Corrections chief executive Ray Smith says the signing of the public private partnership Waikeria contract was still some months away from when the new government came into power. Photo: RNZ / Claire Eastham-Farrelly
Ray Smith told MPs today [10 July], while there were a number of agreements with the consortium the National government had been working with, the signing of the formal contract was still some months away.
The coalition government has been under pressure to explain why it has proceeded with a $750m PPP after Labour MPs vocally opposed using the private sector to build anything other than transport infrastructure.
National said the fact the contract had not been signed showed the coalition government could have pulled out of the PPP if it had really wanted to.
"Whether the government has been deliberately duplicitous or simply chaotic... it is yet another example of its shambolic handling of law and order," National's Corrections spokesperson David Bennett said.
Back in June, while defending the decision to stick with the PPP, ministers David Clark and Andrew Little both told Parliament there was already a contract in place "and it cost $34m".
Corrections Minister Kelvin Davis was drilled about that at select committee, and was asked by opposition MPs why the government had decided to push ahead with the PPP.
Corrections Deputy chief executive Jeremy Lightfoot told the committee in December last year a decision was made to appoint a "preferred bidder" for the PPP arrangements and provided advice to the minister about how that "could be pursued".
National MP Nick Smith accused the government of misleading voters by campaigning against PPPs, then happily adopting one once in power.
Mr Davis had one line in response, one he repeated to every question about the PPP: "I'm happy that the prison will be built, and Corrections will be running it".
Speaking after the hearing, Corrections chief executive Ray Smith would not be drawn on whether Parliament had been misled.
However, he said there would have been a cost to the government if it had decided to abandon the PPP.
"Fortunately, the project has gone ahead... if the project had been cancelled altogether there would have been a cost associated with that, but we're not in that position."
There would have been a $5m "liability" for the government if the agreements had been breached, plus the cost of the work that had already been agreed to, Mr Smith said.
Mr Bennett said it was clear the statements from Dr Clark and Mr Little "were incorrect" but "whether ministers were being deliberately misleading or were simply confused remains to be seen".
Mr Little said he was not going to "dance on the head of a pin" when asked if he had misled Parliament.
He said the question in the House was about a "contract" and he was referring to "procurement agreements" for the design work.
"There was an agreement let and entered into, and I'm confident about the advice that I received in a meeting with other ministers about the cost of exiting the agreement."
New Zealand's public broadcaster, providing comprehensive NZ news and current affairs, specialist audio features and documentaries.
Radio New Zealand is a Crown entity established under the Radio New Zealand Act 1995. Radio New Zealand News are vital elements in our programming, providing impartial news and information to New Zealanders every day. Radio New Zealand (RNZ) provides listeners with exciting and independent radio programmes in accordance with the Radio New Zealand Charter.

Next in Comment

Viva Scoop 3.0! Rounding Up 2018 and Looking Ahead
By: Joseph Cederwall
Gordon Campbell on whether Trump is likely to be impeached
By: Gordon Campbell
Having it All Ways: Scott Morrison’s Jerusalem “Compromise”
By: Binoy Kampmark
Gordon Campbell on the Brexit & Huawei clusterfudges
By: Gordon Campbell
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights at 70
Gordon Campbell on Judgment Day for Theresa May
By: Gordon Campbell
Scoop's PledgeMe Campaign Finishes Today - With $1644 Needed
By: Alastair Thompson
Open Letter Part 2: Who Are Scoop's Biggest Freeriders?
By: Alastair Thompson
Why We Care about Scoop, and Why We Think You Should
By: Joseph Cederwall
It's Crunch Time For - An Open Letter To Readers
By: Alastair Thompson
Saving The News
By: Alastair Thompson
Building a Community Newsroom – the “Scoop 3.0” Transition
By: Joseph Cederwall
Stop Freeriding: Help Scoop Survive (and Thrive!)
By: Joseph Cederwall
Your Organisation Can Now Sponsor a Section on!
By: Scoop Publishing
Scoop Section Sponsorships: An Opportunity to Collaborate
By: Joseph Cederwall
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media