UAE blocks social networking websites
by Ron Callari
The network StumbleUpon has become the latest casualty of the United Arab Emirates’ (UAE) web blocking lottery. It is a
sad commentary when social networking and content sharing sites get auto-blocked by Etisalat, one of the UAE’s largest telecommunications and Internet providers.
StumbleUpon, which is owned by eBay, is a Web browser plug-in and internet community that allows its users to discover
and rate Web pages, photos, and videos
The site joins other social networking services banned by Etisalat, including micro-blogging service Twitter, social networking site Orkut, and the photo sharing platform Flickr.
It is curious that while these sites are blocked to Etisalat customers, those connecting through the country’s rival operator du are still able to access them.
Paradoxically, while Etisalat’s website encourages its subscribers to “find new markets… in international markets,” it obviously doesn’t alert them
that as Big Brother, it will control exactly which markets they deem appropriate.
What is most disturbing to me personally is that a social networking website that I built on July 13, 2008 was censored
in the UAE the following day, on July 14, 2008. The Hotel SEO Executives is a group that tallies only 20 members to date. It is a network of hoteliers and SEO executives worldwide that
collaboratively exchange ideas and information pertaining to search engine optimization in the hotel industry. Hardly a
threatening group! Definitely not an organization that would harm “the religious, cultural, political and moral values
of the United Arab Emirates!” But yet a Hyatt Dubai hotel executive was blocked by Etisalat from registering on just that site.
I understand the desire among the leader's of the UAE to protect their culture, and in particular, their children. By
all means, carry on blocking adult content, or hate sites, even gambling, but randomly blocking the next generation of
online services for no reason doesn't help anyone.
Given some of the licentious material online today, I applaud their concern. However, the current regulatory regime and
the way the rules are implemented goes beyond the need for protection. Blocking these sites doesn't just cut social and
economic opportunity today; it hinders educational and societal development tomorrow.
A generation raised with Internet services that are curtailed and shut off won't become the next generation of thought
leaders. We can’t afford closed communication in today’s world. Wars have been started for less, as we are all painfully
aware.
Prophetically, Etisalat’s advertising tagline is “Reach out. The world’s waiting.” Yes, indeed, we should all be indignantly waiting… for a world that does not impose restrictions, without a sound rationale!
*************
Ron Callari is the Chief Marketing Officer of iOptimize Marketing, an Internet marketing firm, and a freelance journalist and editorial cartoonist whose work has appeared in Alternet, Counterpunch, Sacramento News & Review, Albion Monitor and the World and I. Ron is the Group Administrator of the Hotel SEO Executives.