Meditations - From Martin LeFevre in California Cybermind or Awakened Mind?
Neuroscientists and cutting edge computer developers are in the first stages of building a “bridge between flesh and
chip.” Chillingly, promoters speak of a “brave new world” of thought-controlled machines--in the opposite way that
Aldous Huxley used the term! Just what are the implications of directly linking the brain with the computer?
Not surprisingly, much of the funding for the technology of “brain actuated control” is coming from the Defense
Department. The US government, in its desire to maintain absolute military superiority, is concerned about the load that
existing technologies are putting on its fighter pilots. Technologies are being developed that would enable pilots to
choose weapon systems by merely thinking about them, and to fly their bombing missions from the ground, without risking
precious American lives.
Giving the priority to killing without risking being killed, rather than, oh say, enabling a paraplegic to directly
control machines with his or her mind, is a superlative example of how science and intelligence are two completely
distinct things. But the problem goes way beyond the prevailing military and market mentality.
Indeed, the problem is not science and technology at all, but the lack of insight and wisdom in the use of developments
that are coming online faster than anyone could have imagined even a few years ago. At a deeper level, technologies that
‘unlock the secrets of the mind to harness its power directly, and create thought-controlled machines’ raise urgent,
fundamental questions about the human mind, and what it means to be a human being.
“Brain actuated control,” or, in plain English, a direct link between thought and machine, presents the possibility of
either freeing the human mind, or enslaving it completely. The trends in both history and present society do not bode
well for the first prospect, that of human freedom. As things are going, the mental control of machines means a growing
intellectual dependency on them, and a growing control of the minds of the masses by the few.
There is a real and present danger to the essential unity of the brain, to its capacity for insight, arising from the
healthy and balanced functioning of all of its systems together. By thoughtlessly welding the brain to the computer, we
will lose capacities that we are only beginning to discover. The brain has abilities we don’t as yet know and haven’t
explored, much less understood. Therefore caution and questioning are the order of the day.
Scientists are discovering what so-called mystics have always known—that the brain has powers that go far beyond the
physical boundaries of the skull. However, such things as direct influence on machines (look Ma, no wires!), telepathy,
clairvoyance, remote sensing, etc., though they are being shown to exist scientifically, aren’t important in themselves.
What is essential is the brain’s capacity for insight, which is the foundation of wisdom and understanding. That
capacity is completely distinct from thought.
Because of its power to remove components from nature (which was undivided before man), and manipulate ‘things’ (now at
even the molecular level) at will, we strongly tend to glorify thought. Indeed, many people have a subconscious attitude
of idolatry toward it. The current fascination with all manner of technological gadgets is a symptom of overvaluing the
human mind and its products. In truth, there is nothing more boring than technology for technology’s sake.
What will happen when we’re able to directly control machines with our thoughts? Without invoking the customary fear of
being controlled by machines, how will the direct interface with computers change us? Will humans be reduced to “cyber
minds,” a combination of biological and silicon substrate?
Machines are already outpacing us, as anyone knows who feels a moment’s impatience while moving a mouse to an icon
across the computer screen. We are already being told, ‘our bodies are getting in the way,’ because the brain-eye
connection is so much faster than the brain-hand capability. What is the ostensible solution? Hook the brain up directly
to computers by splicing silicon chips with neuronal tissue, and abracadabra, we’re one with our machines!
It is already possible, through electrodes attached to the skull, to directly mentally control, to a rudimentary degree,
simulation programs and video games. Properly connected, and with a little biofeedback training, you merely think which
way you want the car or plane to go on the screen, for example, and it happens.
The brain is immeasurably more than thought. Thought controlled machines have their place, but too close a link with the
computer, and the brain’s nearly untapped capacity for insight will be lost forever.
************
- Martin LeFevre is a contemplative, and non-academic religious and political philosopher. He has been publishing in
North America, Latin America, Africa, and Europe (and now New Zealand) for 20 years. Email: martinlefevre@sbcglobal.net. The author welcomes comments.