Rove And Cheney Are Now Caught In Fitzgerald's Web. Will They Go Down Too?
Now it’s about the Niger forgeries.
On Friday, after securing a five-count criminal indictment against Vice President Dick Cheney’s Chief of Staff, I. Lewis “Scooter” Libby, for lying
to a grand jury
about what he knew and when he knew it in regard to the outing of a covert CIA agent, Special Prosecutor Patrick
Fitzgerald plans to pursue broader conspiracy charges against Cheney senior White House officials, and top officials at
the State Department and the National Security Council.
Fitzgerald's further inquiries may finally shed light on how the Bush administration came to use erroneous intelligence
that claimed Iraq tried to purchase yellowcake uranium from Niger, lawyers involved in the two year old investigation
While many federal officials and the media have long speculated that Fitzgerald was not only looking into the identity
of administration officials who leaked undercover CIA operative Valerie Plame Wilson to a handful of reporters, it was
only recently that those rumors were confirmed.
According to a court filing posted on the website of Patrick Fitzgerald, the special prosecutor investigating who leaked
the name of undercover CIA agent to reporters, was interested in questioning New York Times reporter Judith Miller about
the CIA agent or whether she discussed Iraq's alleged efforts to purchase uranium from Niger.
"On August 12 and August 20, 2004, grand jury subpoenas were issued to reporter Judith Miller and her employer, the New
York Times, seeking documents and testimony related to “conversations between Miller and a specified government official
occurring between on or about July 6, 2003 and on or about July 13, 2003, concerning Valerie Plame Wilson (whether
referred to by name or by description) or concerning Iraqi efforts to obtain uranium .” the filing made by Fitzgerald last year states
NATO sources told United Press International that Fitzgerald's team of investigators has sought and obtained
documentation on the forgeries from the Italian government.
According to the report
, "Fitzgerald's team has been given the full, and as yet unpublished report of the Italian parliamentary inquiry into
the affair, which started when an Italian journalist obtained documents that appeared to show officials of the
government of Niger helping to supply the Iraqi regime of Saddam Hussein with Yellowcake uranium.
This claim, which made its way into President Bush's State of the Union address in January, 2003, was based on falsified
documents from Niger and was withdrawn by the White House one day after former Ambassador Joseph Wilson wrote an op-ed
in the New York Times in July 2003 disputing the administration’s claims that Iraq tried to purchase uranium from Niger.
It was Wilson’s op-ed and public criticism of the Iraq war that led officials such as Libby to blow Plame’s cover in an
attempt to discredit Wilson - Plame’s husband - who went on a fact finding mission to Niger in February 2002 to
investigate the uranium allegations. In outing Plame’s covert status to reporters, Libby and other officials were trying
to show that Wilson’s trip was a boondoggle that was set up by Plame.
But Fitzgerald’s investigation into the leak has led to many discoveries by the prosecutor, one of which is that Cheney
played a key role in the leak, and the reason was to closely guard the fact that the White House knowingly used false
intelligence, specifically the Niger documents, to build a case for war against Iraq.
Over the past month, Fitzgerald has turned his attention to a little known cabal of administration hawks known as the
White House Iraq Group (WHIG), which came together in August 2002 to publicize the threat posed by Saddam Hussein. WHIG
was founded by Bush chief of staff Andrew Card and operated out of the Vice President’s office.
Fitzgerald’s examination centers on a group of players charged with not only selling the war, but according to sources
familiar with the case, to discredit anyone who openly “disagreed with the official Iraq war” story.
The group’s members included Deputy White House chief of staff Karl Rove, Bush advisor Karen Hughes, Senior Advisor to
the Vice President Mary Matalin, Deputy Director of Communications James Wilkinson, Assistant to the President and
Legislative Liaison Nicholas Calio, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, National Security Advisor Stephen Hadley and I.
Lewis “Scooter” Libby - Chief of Staff to the Vice President and co-author of the Administration's pre-emptive strike
Rice was later appointed Secretary of State; her deputy Hadley was made National Security Advisor. Wilkinson departed to
become a spokesman for the military's central command, and later for the Republican National Convention. Hughes was
recently appointed Under Secretary of State.
Several members of the group have testified before Fitzgerald’s grand jury.
Cheney’s role under scrutiny
Two officials close to Fitzgerald said they have seen documents obtained from the White House Iraq Group which state
that Cheney was present at several of the group's meetings.
They say Cheney personally discussed with individuals in attendance at least two interviews in May and June of 2003
Wilson gave to New York Times columnist Nicholas Kristof and Washington Post reporter Walter Pincus, in which he claimed
the administration “twisted” pre-war intelligence and what the response from the administration should be.
Cheney was interviewed by the FBI surrounding the leak in 2004. According to the New York Times, Cheney was asked
whether he knew of any concerted effort by White House aides to name Ms. Wilson.
Sources close to the investigation have also confirmed that special prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald is trying to determine
Vice President Cheney's role in the outing of Mrs. Wilson, more specifically, if Cheney ordered the leak.
Those close to Fitzgerald say they have yet to uncover any evidence that suggests Cheney ordered the leak or played a
role in the outing of Mrs. Wilson. Still, the sources said, they are investigating claims that Cheney may have been
involved based on his attendance at meetings of the Iraq group. Previous reports indicate Cheney was intimately involved
with the framing of the Iraq war.
Earlier this month, The Wall Street Journal confirmed that the Iraq group was under scrutiny.
“Formed in August 2002, the group, which included Messrs. [Karl] Rove and [Lewis] Libby, worked on setting strategy for
selling the war in Iraq to the public in the months leading up to the March 2003 invasion,” the Journal reported. “The
group likely would have played a significant role in responding to [former Ambassador Joseph] Wilson's claims” that the
Bush administration twisted intelligence when it said Iraq tried to acquire yellow-cake uranium from Africa.
Rove's "strategic communications" task force operating inside the group was instrumental in writing and coordinating
speeches by senior Bush administration officials, highlighting in September 2002 that Iraq was a nuclear threat.
The White House Iraq Group operated virtually unknown until January 2004, when Fitzgerald subpoenaed for notes, email
and attendance records. Bush Chief of Staff Andrew H. Card Jr. created the group in August of 2002.
“A senior official who participated in its work called it "an internal working group, like many formed for priority
issues, to make sure each part of the White House was fulfilling its responsibilities, "according to an Aug. 10, 2003,
Washington Post investigative report
on the group’s inner workings.
Senior Bush adviser Karl Rove chaired meetings of the group.
The group relied heavily on New York Times reporter Judith Miller, who, after meeting with several of the organization’s
members in August 2002, wrote an explosive story that many critics of the war believe laid the groundwork for military
action against Iraq.
On Sunday, Sept. 8, 2002, Miller wrote a story for the Times quoting anonymous officials who said aluminium tubes found
in Iraq were to be used as centrifuges. Her report said the "diameter, thickness and other technical specifications" of
the tubes -- precisely the grounds for scepticism among nuclear enrichment experts -- showed that they were "intended as
components of centrifuges."
She closed her piece by quoting then-National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice who said the United States would not sit
by and wait to find a smoking gun to prove its case, possibly in the form of a “a mushroom cloud."
After Miller’s piece was published, administration officials pursued their case on Sunday talk shows using Miller’s
piece as evidence that Iraq was pursuing a nuclear bomb, even though those officials were the ones who supplied Miller
with the story and were quoted anonymously.
Rice's comments on CNN’s “Late Edition” reaffirmed Miller’s story. Rice said that Saddam Hussein was "actively pursuing
a nuclear weapon" and that the tubes -- described repeatedly in U.S. intelligence reports as "dual-use" items -- were
"only really suited for nuclear weapons programs, centrifuge programs."
Cheney, on NBC's "Meet the Press," also mentioned the aluminium tubes story in the Times and said "increasingly, we
believe the United States will become the target" of an Iraqi atomic bomb. Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld, on
CBS's "Face the Nation," asked viewers to "imagine a September 11th with weapons of mass destruction.”
President Bush reiterated the image of Rice’s mushroom cloud comment in his Oct. 7, 2002 speech.
The International Atomic Energy Agency later revealed that Iraq’s aluminium tubes were never designed to enrich uranium.
In February of 2003, WHIG allegedly scripted the speech Powell made to the United Nations presenting the United States’
case for war.
Powell’s speech to the UN, United Press International reported, “was handled by the White House Iraq Group, which…
provided Powell with a script for his speech, using information developed by [Douglas] Feith's group [The Office Of
Strategic Plans (OSP) in the Pentagon]. Much of it was unsourced material fed to newspapers by the OSP. Realizing this,
Powell's team turned to the now-discredited National Intelligence Estimate on Iraq. But some of Feith's handiwork ended
up in Powell's mouth anyway.”
During its very first meetings, Card's Iraq group ordered a series of white papers showing Iraq’s arms violations. The
first paper, "A Grave and Gathering Danger: Saddam Hussein's Quest for Nuclear Weapons," was never published. However,
the paper was drafted with the assistance of experts from the National Security Council and Cheney's office.
“In its later stages, the draft white paper coincided with production of a National Intelligence Estimate and its
unclassified summary. “But the WHIG, according to three officials who followed the white paper's progress, wanted
gripping images and stories not available in the hedged and austere language of intelligence,” according to the Post.
Eight months later, Joseph Wilson began to question the veracity of the Bush administration’s pre-war intelligence in
private conversations with reporters. His accusations threatened to undercut the administration’s successful marketing
campaign: that Iraq was an imminent threat to the United States and its neighbours in the Middle East.
Now Fitzgerald is trying to find out what Cheney knew. Attorneys close to the case said its very likely Cheney could be
named as an un-indicted co-conspirator when the probe wraps up.
And while Karl Rove may have escaped indictment on the day many believed Fitzgerald would announce the investigation has
ended, his fate still hangs in legal limbo.
Fitzgerald is betting on the fact that he can secure an indictment against Rove on charges of perjury, obstructions of
justice, the misuse of classified information, and possibly other charges, as early as next week.
Over the past week, several people involved in the case -- from the State Department and the National Security Council
-- who faced imminent indictment for their role in unmasking Plame to reporters have agreed to cooperate with Fitzgerald
and have provided him with information that will help the prosecutor build a stronger case against Rove and other key
figures, the lawyers said.
“This investigation is not yet over,” one of the lawyers in the case said. “You must keep in mind that people like Mr.
Rove are still under investigation. Rather than securing an indictment on perjury charges against Mr. Rove, Mr.
Fitzgerald strongly believes he can convince the grand jury that he broke other laws.”
The lawyers said that in the past month Fitzgerald has obtained explosive information in the case that has enabled him
to pursue broader charges against Rove and other top officials such as conspiracy, and violating Plame and Wilson’s
And in a sign that could spell further trouble for the Bush White House, the 22-page indictment against I. Lewis
“Scooter” Libby, Vice President Dick Cheney’s chief of staff, implicated former Under Secretary of State Marc Grossman,
as well as other aides who worked indirectly on behalf of the vice president’s office, as the person who first obtained
and disseminated covert CIA agent Valerie Plame Wilson’s identity to Libby.
According to the indictment, “on or about May 29, 2003, in the White House, LIBBY asked an Under Secretary of State
(“Under Secretary”) for information concerning the unnamed ambassador’s travel to Niger to investigate claims about
Iraqi efforts to acquire uranium yellowcake. The Under Secretary thereafter directed the State Department’s Bureau of
Intelligence and Research to prepare a report concerning the ambassador and his trip. The Under Secretary provided LIBBY
with interim oral reports in late May and early June 2003, and advised LIBBY that Wilson was the former ambassador who
took the trip.”
Lawyers involved in the two year old probe said that two former Cheney aides had a hand in obtaining information about
Wilson and shared it with Libby after the chief of staff had personally requested such information.
Those aides, David Wurmser and John Hannah, are now cooperating with Special Prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald’s probe into
the outing of Plame’s identity and CIA status to reporters. Wurmser and Hannah have agreed to cooperate with Fitzgerald
after being told that they faced indictment for their role in outing Plame.
The officials had told Fitzgerald that they were acting on orders from then Under Secretary of State for Arms Control
and International Security [now UN Ambassador] John Bolton to obtain such information.
Hannah a key aide to Vice President Dick Cheney and one of the architects of the Iraq war, and Wurmser was Cheney’s
Middle East advisor and an assistant to Bolton.
Wurmser’s cooperation with Fitzgerald would certainly come as no surprise to those who have been following his career.
Last year, he was questioned by the Federal Bureau of Investigation for his possible role in leaking U.S. security
secrets to Israel.
According to a 2004 story in the Washington Post, the FBI interviewed officials in Cheney’s office and the Pentagon,
including Hannah and Wurmser, former Defense Policy Board member Richard Perle, Under Secretary of Defense Douglas Feith
and Deputy Defense Secretary Paul Wolfowitz, to determine if they were involved in leaking U.S. security secrets to
Israel, the former head of the Iraqi National Congress Ahmed Chalabi and the American Israel Public Affairs Committee
The revelation that Hannah and Wurmser have become prosecution witnesses, as well as being identified as the original
sources of the leak, indicates Fitzgerald now may be looking into the motive for outing Plame and how Administration
officials sought to derail a vocal critic of Iraq intelligence.
Libby resigned moments after he learned that he was indicted.
The only sitting Cabinet member to be indicted in recent history was President Reagan's labor secretary, Raymond J.
Donovan. Accused of grand larceny in 1984, he was acquitted in 1987. H.R. Haldeman, chief of staff to President Nixon,
resigned before being indicted -- and convicted -- in the Watergate coverup.
Expected to replace Libby as Cheney’s chief of staff is David Addington, a principal author of the White House memo
justifying the torture of terrorism suspects. He also strongly endorsed holding suspects without access to the legal
system, a measure rebuked by the Supreme Court.
The Cheney loyalist has also defended the Vice President's right to withhold information about his meetings with energy
company executives, much to the chagrin of environmentalists.
ADDENDUM: The June 10th INR memo cited in the Libby indictment was written by Carl Ford, Assistant Secretary of State
for Intelligence and Research for Under Secretary of State Marc Grossman at the request of then-Under Secretary of State
for Arms Control John Bolton, who was asked to do so by Libby. Ford is the person who testified before a senate
committee convened to question Bolton during his United Nations confirmation hearing that Bolton was a “bully.”
© 2005 Jason Leopold
John Byrne and Larisa Alexandrovna of RAW STORY contributed to this story
Jason Leopold is the author of the explosive memoir, News Junkie, to be released in the spring of 2006 by Process/Feral
House Books. Visit Leopold's website at www.jasonleopold.com