Terror Alerts - Substance or Politics?
By Howard Dean
Wednesday 11 August 2004
Over the past week there has been a lot of controversy about whether President Bush is using the timing of terror
alerts to bolster his re-election campaign. Terrorism is a very serious issue and I do not believe that the terror
alerts are based solely on politics. However, I do have some concerns that the timing of this announcement seems to be
based on an election strategy.
Let's look at the facts:
* Bush strategist Karl Rove told members of the Republican National Committee during a January 2002 speech that
Republicans "can go to the country" on national security issues and invited his party to politicize the war in an
election year. And according to The Associated Press, a White House strategy for the 2002 elections - formulated by top
presidential advisors - advised Republican candidates to campaign with messages highlighting the war on terrorism.
* The Al Qaeda operative whose capture led to the release of information was captured on July 13, twenty days before
President Bush's press conference. The bulk of the information received was over three years old, some was eight months
old. Even if the computer discs were found a few days after the capture of the terrorist, that means that the
administration either chose the timing of the release, presumably for political reasons, or they lacked the resources to
process the information in a timely manner.
* The day after Ridge was accused of considering politics for the timing of the announcement, he suddenly claimed that
it took them a long time to process and translate the information.
* The administration has denied that the Department of Homeland Security gets involved in politics. In fact, last year
the Department of Homeland Security was reportedly used for political purposes when it attempted to track down the
whereabouts of Texas lawmakers who left the state to foil a Republican attempt to gerrymander Texas congressional
districts.
* And, the Department of Homeland Security played the political card again at the press conference on August 1. Ridge
spent time informing Americans that the President was a great leader in the fight against terror. Ridge said, "We must
understand that the kind of information available to us today is the result of the President's leadership in the war
against terror."
* This is not the first or second time this administration has misled the public. For example, Weapons of Mass
Destruction still have not been found in Iraq - even though President Bush convinced the American public and Congress
that this was one of the primary reasons to support sending approximately 135,000 troops to Iraq.
* I am not the only person to believe that the timing of this announcement was somewhat based on politics. News
organizations like the Associated Press, The Washington Post and The New York Times interviewed national security
experts and political strategists, including a "top GOP operative" and "some senior Republicans" who have also
questioned the timing of this announcement.
Terror is one of the most serious short term problems America faces and along with the soaring deficits and the
continuing degradation of our environment, it is one of our most serious long term problems. All of us want the
President to succeed in fighting this incredible threat. I am one American who would like to see more substance and less
politics in this fight, so I can look forward to a future filled with hope, not fear.
*********
Howard Dean, former governor of Vermont, is the founder of Democracy for America, a grassroots organization that
supports socially progressive and fiscally responsible political candidates.