Tragedy A Wake-Up Call For Bar Managers And Owners
Bar owners and bar managers have to take responsibility for what happens on their premises, says the Alcohol Advisory
Council (ALAC).
ALAC Chief Executive Officer Dr Mike MacAvoy says the death of a young patron after injuries suffered in a game of bull
rush at a Palmerston North bar was a tragedy for the young man’s family and friends.
“But the big worry is that his behaviour that night was more a symptom of a broader problem across New Zealand than an
isolated incident that caused this particular tragedy,” says Dr MacAvoy.
“In my mind, two things let that young man down that night. One was the culture of binge drinking in New Zealand that
led these young people to aspire to become intoxicated in the first place. But we do have a culture like that, so we
need laws to protect people as best we can until we see a change. The second let down was the law. Serving intoxicated
people on licensed premises is illegal so he should have been protected by the law that night.”
Dr MacAvoy says he hopes this incident serves as a wake-up call for all bar managers and owners and emphasises the need
for them to fulfil their obligations as licence holders.
“Bar owners and managers need to be vigilant and keep a watch on their patrons. In this case, the four young men
involved were being served at least four tray lots of 16 double bourbons and any responsible manager should have been
alerted to the possibility of harm resulting.”
Dr MacAvoy was commenting following an inquest yesterday into the death of William Cranswick, 19, who died after
injuries suffered in a game of bull rush at The Fitz bar in Palmerston North in September 2003. He had been drinking
with a group of three friends. At an earlier Liquor Licensing Authority Hearing, which took away the general manager’s
licence, the authority said the group were ordering drinks by the tray each consisting of 16 double bourbons and coke.
Coroner Graham Hubbard said he would make recommendations regarding the sale of liquor. The recommendations would focus
on the suitability of selling tray loads of drinks to customers; allowing physical contact sports to be played in public
bars; and improving the training given to bar managers so they were all aware that any injuries should be reported.
Dr MacAvoy says ALAC looks forward to seeing the coroner’s recommendations.
ALAC had been working with the Justice Department and the industry on a new Licence Controller qualification which was
due to come into force later this year.
“This qualification places the emphasis on ensuing that bar managers not only know the theory behind host responsibility
but can also put it into practice. All bar managers will eventually have to upgrade to this qualification to obtain or
renew their general manager’s licence.”