In our lead story this week…..
EDUCATION AMENDMENT BILL COMES UNDER ATTACK
The Association of University Staff has urged Parliament's Education and Science Select Committee to defer consideration
of some sections of the Education Amendment (No.2) Bill, saying it poses the greatest threat to the distinctive role of
universities since the tertiary education reforms of 1989-90. Presenting the AUS submissions to the committee, Executive
Director, Rob Crozier called for parts of the Bill that allow the Minister of Education to dissolve a University Council
and replace it with a Commissioner to be put aside. “The concept of having one person running a university with total
responsibility for all academic matters in addition to financial is mind-boggling," he said. He pointed out that the
recently-completed TEAC report, Shaping the System, is calling for a substantive review of the Education Act 1989 as it
relates to tertiary education. As a result, any decisions on clauses in the of the present Bill that had the "potential
for political interference in the administration of universities" should be deferred until that review had taken place.
Also in Tertiary Update this week:
1. What the papers say on the Bill
2. Fogelberg warns of medical staffing crisis at university
3. TEAC report summary in Maori
4. Polytech payout details released
5. Canada targets education in GATS
6. Australian universities check out 'soft marking'
7. US colleges ban study in UK
WHAT THE PAPERS SAY ON THE BILL
The "Manawatu Evening Standard", in an editorial on the Education Amendment Bill, asks "Do our universities really have
something to fear from government moves to change the law to give the state the power to intervene if institutions get
into financial strife?" It is, the newspaper suggests, a tricky business balancing the historic autonomy which
universities have traditionally enjoyed with their accountability as taxpayer-funded bodies. It notes that the Tertiary
Education Minister and one-time Massey University academic, Steve Maharey has been quick to reassure the universities
they have nothing to fear from his plans. But, the newspaper concludes – almost unbidden – images of roads and the good
intentions with which they are paved spring to mind!
In its editorial on the topic, the "New Zealand Herald" takes issue with the provisions of the Bill that would allow the
Minister to appoint an "observer" to the University Council if he or she considers "the operation or long-term viability
of the institution is at risk." With what purpose, wonders the newspaper, given that there are already four
government-appointed members of the Council? The purpose, the editorial concludes, is as a "spy" since the observer "may
report to the minister on any matter raised or discussed at any meeting." The observer then would work for the minister,
whereas the minister's appointees to the council owe prior allegiance to the university. The "Herald" also takes issue
with the provision allowing the minister to appoint a commissioner to replace the council, suggesting "an insidious
centralisation of power" that is taking place in public health and education is now spreading to the tertiary sector.
The editorial's conclusion:"…there is no justification for the government to interfere. It must be stopped." We couldn't
have put it better.
FOGELBERG WARNS OF MEDICAL STAFFING CRISIS AT UNIVERSITY
The Vice-Chancellor of Otago University, Dr Graeme Fogelberg has written to the Minister of Health, Hon. Annette King,
warning that the disparities between university-level pay and hospital rates have been causing a recruitment and
retention "crisis" at the university. He told the university's finance and budget committee he understood "top flight"
Auckland hospital pathologists were paid about $260,000, whereas the combined payment a university pathologist could
expect was about $100,000 below that. He said this explained why there had been delays in appointing a replacement
pathology professor at its Christchurch School of Medicine. University salaries had failed to keep pace with other
sectors over the past five years, and the weak state of the dollar also posed problems for overseas recruitment. He
indicated that medicine was not the only discipline facing recruitment problems. Two attempts to fill the post of the
Donald Collie Professor of English had failed. Meanwhile, Dr Fogelberg and the Chair of the New Zealand
Vice-Chancellors' Committee, Professor James McWha, are seeking a meeting with senior government ministers to discuss
the funding problems, but as yet no date has been set for the meeting. “Tertiary Update” is pleased that the
Vice-Chancellor has finally recognised the problem and seems intent on doing something about it. AUS has been raising
this problem for many years and, in the last 3 years in particular, has identified a potential crisis in medical
teaching and research in our medical schools.
TEAC REPORT SUMMARY IN MAORI
The summary of the "Shaping the System" report has now been issued in the Maori language. It can be viewed at
http://www.teac.govt.nz/documents/system/punaha.pdf
POLYTECH PAYOUT DETAILS RELEASED
It has been revealed that Aoraki Polytechnic paid former naturopathy students $515,000 in settlement of a dispute over
the standing of their course. Thirty-six students took a case against the Polytechnic in 1999 after the New Zealand
Qualifications Authority rejected the course on all but two of the 19 criteria. The students said they had been led to
believe they would receive a Bachelor of Applied Science in naturopathy at the end of their three years of study.
Details of the previously secret settlement were made public after an investigation by the Chief Ombudsman.
Incidentally, AUS actively campaigned at the time against naturopathy being taught as an Applied Science degree.
WORLD WATCH
CANADA TARGETS EDUCATION IN GATS TALKS
The Canadian government has given notice that it will aggressively promote the export of educational services in the
upcoming negotiations under the General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS). The Trade Minister, Pierre Pettigrew said
the government would "work hard to increase export opportunities for Canadian health and educational services", while at
the same time protecting its domestic public services from access by foreign firms. The President of the Canadian
Association of University Teachers (CAUT), Tom Booth suggests the government is "naïve" to think it can win access to
foreign education markets while keeping up barriers to its own education market.
AUSTRALIAN UNIVERSITIES CHECK OUT 'SOFT MARKING'
Australian universities have begun checks on 'soft marking' after concerns were raised by the Senate inquiry into public
universities which began hearings last week. New South Wales and Curtin Universities have set up formal inquiries to see
if the fears that inappropriate high marks are being given, or existing marks are being upgraded without adequate
grounds, have substance. Deakin and Wollongong have begun informal checks through deans, and vice-chancellors at
Murdoch, Sydney and New England have called for anyone with information about soft marking to come forward. To date they
have had no response.
US COLLEGES BAN STUDY IN UK
The outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease in Europe has upset study-abroad programmes for students at several American
universities. Michigan State University has cancelled a summer programme in the UK and Ireland for 30 agriculture
students and faculty. It has also recalled a student who was on an exchange to the Greenmount College of Agriculture and
Horticulture in Northern Ireland – where the disease was detected among campus animals. Purdue University has cancelled
two of its students' summer farm stays in Ireland and the University of Wisconsin has begun to limit foreign visitors to
its College of Agriculture, turning away a group of 50 German farmers.
***************************************************************************
AUS Tertiary Update is produced weekly on Thursdays and distributed freely to members of the union and others. Back
issues are archived on the AUS website: