INDEPENDENT NEWS

Former Mainzeal directors in final-hour appeal of judgment

Published: Tue 26 Mar 2019 08:29 PM
Former Mainzeal directors in final-hour appeal of judgment
By Nikki Mandow
March 26 (BusinessDesk) - Directors of collapsed construction company Mainzeal, including former Prime Minister Jenny Shipley, are appealing last month’s High Court judgment.
The decision found them liable for up to $6 million each following $110 million of losses suffered by creditors when the company went into liquidation.
Former Mainzeal chair Shipley and two other former directors, Clive Tilby and Peter Gomm, say the High Court was wrong to say they breached their duties under section 135 of the Companies Act. They say that they shouldn’t have to pay anything to sub-contractors and other creditors.
Making the announcement on the last day for appeals to be lodged, the directors’ QC, Jack Hodder, criticised the way Justice Francis Cooke awarded damages.
“The judge took a novel approach to the case, an approach that wasn’t open to him.”
This involved awarding damages using a formula based on the final amount owed to creditors, rather than the more “orthodox” Mason v Lewis approach. The latter involves working out how much less creditors would have been owed had the directors pulled the plug earlier.
Shipley and the other directors argued that creditors were actually better off in 2013 than they would have been if Mainzeal had been liquidated earlier - and the judge agreed.
Hodder also said the judge was wrong to argue the directors should have known Mainzeal’s Chinese parent Richina Pacific wouldn’t come up with money to bail the company out when it was in dire straits.
He says there had been $12 million of support in the year before the company failed, and plenty of commitment to financial help.
“We argue there was sufficient group support for Mainzeal. We said $12 million was supplied in the last 12 months, and there were indications there would be support for Mainzeal at all times.”
Justice Cooke ruled that the three directors were reckless, “had adopted a policy of trading while insolvent”, and “used money owed to trade operators, particularly sub-contractors, as working capital.
“The assurances relied upon were ambiguous, conditional, and subject to the constraints of Chinese law, which restricted the ability to return money to New Zealand from China,” Justice Cooke said in the judgment.
Hodder argues the three directors “have good grounds to appeal”.
“The company was not carrying on business in a manner likely to cause serious loss to creditors.”
He says winning the appeal would mean the directors had nothing to pay - and creditors would get nothing. Anything less, for example reduced damages, "would be a very partial win.”
Yesterday, a fourth Mainzeal director, Richina Pacific boss Richard Yan, also appealed the High Court judgment. While Shipley, Gomm and Tilby were found liable for up to $6 million each, Yan is potentially liable for the full amount, $36 million.
Liquidator BDO now also has the option to cross-appeal within 10 working days. The appeal is likely to be heard later this year and could take about a week, Hodder estimated.
He said the directors won’t be making any further comment.
(BusinessDesk)
BusinessDesk
Independent, Trustworthy New Zealand Business News
The Wellington-based BusinessDesk team provides a daily news feed for a serious business audience.
Contact BusinessDesk
Email:

Next in Business, Science, and Tech

No New Coal Boilers for Fonterra
By: Fonterra
Soil turned on controversial Waimea Dam
By: RNZ
Drones will help economy take off
By: New Zealand Government
Fuel and rent drive inflation
By: Statistics New Zealand
Fonterra to go coal-free 11 years ahead of schedule
By: BusinessDesk
Government welcomes Fonterra’s speedy moves away from coal
By: New Zealand Government
Coal group welcomes Fonterra's coal exit
By: Coal Action Network
Coal Action protest finishes
By: Coal Action Network
Fonterra decision stimulus for increased biomass fuel supply
By: Bioenergy Association
Fonterra’s announcement a win for the climate movement
By: 350 Aotearoa
Methane target could be catastrophic - Shareholders' Council
By: BusinessDesk
Drone integration a flight closer
By: Airways New Zealand
New recommendations on flying drones over marine animals
By: AUT University
Pizza-by-drone a reality with world-first NZ delivery
By: Domino's Pizza
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media