INDEPENDENT NEWS

Judge gets Facebook news primer in media merger hearing

Published: Mon 16 Oct 2017 09:29 PM
High Court judge gets Facebook news primer in media merger hearing
By Sophie Boot
Oct. 16 (BusinessDesk) - Justice Robert Dobson and his self-confessed "Luddite ways" was shown how news can be shared via social media during day one of Stuff and NZME's appeal against the Commerce Commission's rejection of their planned merger.
The video demonstrated how people can see and share news on aggregator and social media sites such as MSN News, Google News, Facebook, Twitter and Youtube.
The Commerce Commission's lawyer James Every-Palmer opposed the video being shown as he said it demonstrated idiosyncratic behaviour and wasn't representative of a normal social media feed, as the Facebook and Twitter accounts shown had no friends and only followed media companies' profiles. The media companies' lawyer David Goddard QC argued that the video was intended to demonstrate the mechanics of how news works on social media and was not supposed to be representative of a normal user experience.
Justice Dobson said he was unfamiliar with Facebook, and lay member Professor Martin Richardson, professor of economics at ANU, said he only used his Facebook account to keep up with his children, so the judge ruled he would see the video as an aid to Goddard's submissions. The Commerce Commission will be able to argue against what was shown in its submissions.
Goddard showed the video after he argued that media companies are in a Faustian pact with social media platforms, particularly Facebook, as they need to have a presence and publish their stories on those platforms in order to be visible to more readers, but the platforms capture the advertising revenue and marketing data as users don't click through to the news websites.
NZX-listed NZME and Stuff, the recently renamed New Zealand arm of ASX-listed Fairfax Media, applied to merge in 2015, arguing the downside of more concentrated local media ownership would be offset by the merged entity's greater ability to survive the global competition for local advertising dollars caused by the rise of online search and social media giants such as Google and Facebook.
In May, the commission concluded the merger would have too detrimental an impact on media 'plurality' - the number of competing sources of reporting and opinion that it argued was essential to the media's role as an important element of a well-functioning democracy. Fairfax and NZME filed their appeal later that month, claiming the regulator was wrong in fact and in law in rejecting the merger.
The appeal was set down for a 10-day hearing in the Wellington High Court from today.
(BusinessDesk)
BusinessDesk
Independent, Trustworthy New Zealand Business News
The Wellington-based BusinessDesk team led by former Bloomberg Asian top editor Jonathan Underhill and Qantas Award-winning journalist and commentator Pattrick Smellie provides a daily news feed for a serious business audience.
Contact BusinessDesk
Email:

Next in Business, Science, and Tech

Feds Applaud Fonterra On Bold Climate Change Announcement
By: Federated Farmers
Decision to Delay Monitoring ‘Fatally Flawed’
By: Maui and Hector's Dolphin Defenders
Kaikoura District Council – One year on
By: Kaikoura District Council
Fonterra Launches Plan to Improve Waterways
By: Fonterra
Targets good first step but Fonterra must reduce dairy herd
By: Greenpeace New Zealand
Our rivers need more than empty headlines from Fonterra
By: Greenpeace New Zealand
Fonterra pledges 13 more years of new coal boilers
By: Coal Action Network
Fonterra pledge will build on existing initiatives
By: Federated Farmers
Bioenergy Association congratulates Fonterra
By: Bioenergy Association
Greens Fail Dolphins
By: New Zealand National Party
Getting digital monitoring right
By: Seafood New Zealand
Kaikoura recovery by the numbers
By: Statistics New Zealand
Kaikōura Harbour back in business
By: New Zealand Government
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media