One in four dairy farmers in negative cashflow this season, Wheeler says
By Paul McBeth
May 13 (BusinessDesk) - Another year of sagging dairy prices would be a concern for New Zealand's economy and especially
for the 25 percent of farmers currently carrying debts above 65 percent of the value of their assets and currently
trading in negative equity, says Reserve Bank governor Graeme Wheeler.
Expanding at a parliamentary hearing on this morning's release of the central bank's six monthly financial stability
report, which imposed new macro-prudential restrictions on lending on Auckland housing, Wheeler said "another year of
low prices, that would be a worry for the economy, no question, and also that would be a worry for farmers in terms of
their debt capacity."
Prices for whole milk powder dropped an average 1.8 percent to US$2,386 a tonne in last week's GlobalDairyTrade auction,
extending its decline over the past five auctions to 27 percent. Those low prices, which had been caused in part by the
Chinese build-up of inventories during 2013 and the falling cereal prices which allowed less efficient farmers to retain
some margin, are seen as one of three key risks to New Zealand's financial stability if they were to linger, the Reserve
Bank said in its six-monthly financial stability report out today.
The Reserve Bank said there is significant cross-over between farms estimated to have negative cash flows in the current
season and those with high loan-to-value rations above 65 percent. About 25 percent of farmers, who account for about 32
percent of the sector’s $34 billion in debt, are estimated to have negative cash flow this season as milk prices hang
near five-year lows and the outlook remains subdued. The bank estimates about 11 percent of debt is held by farms with
high loan-to-value ratios of above 65 percent.
Wheeler told Parliament's finance and expenditure select committee that the bank estimates prices will return to an
equilibrium price over the medium term of between US$3,200 and US$3,800 per tonne, though market pricing only suggests
it will rise to about US$2,700/tonne by the end of the year.
"If you saw the dairy price just remain at low levels for a considerable period: one, that negative cash flow problem
intensifies; two, you'd probably start to see dairy farm prices fall which would compound the situation," Wheeler said.
The dairy sector, which produces New Zealand’s biggest export commodity, is seen as a risk to the nation’s financial
stability, with low global prices for milk products weighing on cash-flow, particularly for those farms with elevated
levels of debt. Large deferred payments from last season’s record payout have helped mitigate the decline in incomes,
though the Reserve Bank still sees risks for the sector if prices remain low.
The bank said private lenders have a “largely positive view” on the long-term outlook for the dairy sector, and have
been easing credit conditions for working capital.
Deputy governor Grant Spencer told politicians that lending on farms had been fairly stable in recent years, and still
accounted for the bulk of the sector's debt. Farmers had increased borrowing to fund short-term working capital.
Spencer said those farms experiencing negative cash flow in the current season are able to source funding from the
deferred payout from the prior season, short-term bank loans, and cutting back on investment intentions, though that
can't last forever and the more highly geared farms would find themselves struggling to service their loans.
"From our perspective, there is some degree of optimism that farmers hate to walk away from the land," Spencer said.
"They they won't do it lightly and will go to some extraordinary lengths to continue to service the mortgage."