Media statement Wednesday, August 27th, 2008
Electoral Commission decision bans public discussion
The Employers and Manufacturers Association rejects the finding of the Electoral Commission that its newspaper
advertisement was in breach of the Electoral Finance Act.
"Our advertisements run in the Herald, the DomPost and the Sunday Star-Times did not encourage voters to vote, or not to
vote for the Labour Party, or any other political party as the Commission claims in its determination," said Alasdair
Thompson, EMA's chief executive.
"The Commission came to this incorrect conclusion apparently by interpreting wrongly the "impact" of our newspaper ads.
"A reading of its determination makes this clear.
"If the Electoral Commission's decision is allowed to go unchallenged it will prevent or severely restrict public
commentary on all issues of public importance in an election year.
"So we will challenge the decision vigorously.
"Our advertisement asked concerned New Zealanders to contact MP's of all political parties and ask them to stop yet
another change being made to the KiwiSaver law.
"The law change in question being promoted by Trevor Mallard would discriminate against employees who don't join
KiwiSaver.
"Under it employers would be forced to pay staff not in KiwiSaver four per cent less than staff who join the scheme.
"This would create dissension in the workplace and that's the issue our advertisements addressed.
"We asked readers to contact all parliamentary parties to tell them they opposed this proposed law and stop it.
"The decision by the Electoral Commission says it is illegal to advertise opposition to law changes of this sort if the
ads say Stop Mallard passing such a law.
"It says in effect it is illegal to promote any views that oppose those of the government or an MP such as Mr Mallard in
an election year.
"Our advertisement had nothing to do with the election. It focused entirely on a single political issue which Mr Mallard
said would be passed before the election without public consultation.
"The issue in question - the changes to KiwiSaver - had its genesis well before this current election year.
"Our advertisement was not about influencing anyone about how they should vote.
"Today we have lodged a request under the Official Information Act to access the information considered by the
Commission in reaching its decision as a precursor to seeking a Judicial Review of it.
"If the police decide to prosecute we will vigorously defend our right to continue doing what we have done for the past
128 years, which is to lobby Parliament on all business matters, especially those affecting employers and employees."
ENDS