13 January 2006
Slower service for a higher price: duopoly stitch-up hurts broadband users Media release - for immediate release
"Today's announcement of a deal between Telecom and TelstraClear on a range of wholesale matters is good news for
TelstraClear, but potentially bad news for Internet users," said InternetNZ Executive Director Keith Davidson,
commenting on the late-afternoon release of details of a settlement between the two companies.
The deal covers discount for wholesale services including home phone lines, lower interconnection rates and broadband
services.
"In particular the two Unbundled Bitstream Service offerings – 256kb and 3.5mb downstream with 128kb upstream – are
inferior to plans that would have been available to TelstraClear under the Commerce Commission’s UBS determination
announced last year.
"Most New Zealanders will only be able to get broadband at half the speed they would have been able to get under the
Commission’s determination.
"While this is better than the offers currently available, it is truly a case of 'what might have been'," said Keith
Davidson.
"It is also a pity that the two companies could not agree on a faster upstream speed, given that their negotiations were
not bound by the regulatory framework. A lift to the 128kb upstream link would have been a major improvement for New
Zealand broadband consumers.
"128kb upstream in an unbundled Internet service is very slow; such a service is still not true broadband and should not
be described as such. Comparative countries like the UK and Australia have true broadband: so should New Zealand.
"This action today simply shows that the current market structure and the inadequate, light-handed regulatory framework
applying to telecommunications leads to unsatisfactory outcomes for Kiwi consumers.
"We will look forward to seeing David Cunliffe's response, when he makes his plans for regulation public later this
year," Keith Davidson concluded.
ENDS