Rubicon’s Partial Takeover Offer
Auckland, 12 April, 2004 - Tenon Limited announced today that it was sending a letter to its shareholders in respect of
the Notice of a conditional Partial Takeover Offer from Rubicon Forests Limited. The text of this letter is set out
below.
Dear shareholder,
Rubicon’s intention to make a conditional partial takeover offer
On 8 April, Tenon Limited received notice (“Notice”) from Rubicon Forests Limited (“Rubicon”) of its intention to make a
conditional Partial Takeover Offer to increase its interest in the Company to 50.01% by acquiring further shares at a
price of NZ$1.85 per share. Rubicon already owns 19.997% of the Company’s shares.
Tenon’s Independent Directors will consider the intended Partial Takeover Offer. Tenon Directors Michael Andrews and
Luke Moriarty, respectively chairman and chief executive of Rubicon, will not participate in this process.
Shareholders should take no action in relation to the Notice
Shareholders are strongly advised not to take any action in relation to the Notice from Rubicon until the Independent
Directors of Tenon complete an assessment of the actual offer from Rubicon and have provided shareholders with a formal
recommendation and a report on the merits of the offer from an Independent Advisor.
The Independent Directors’ objective in considering the Notice and any subsequent formal offer to shareholders is to
ensure that shareholder value is maximised.
The offer is only marginally above Tenon’s closing share price
Shareholders should note that the price of NZ$1.85 offers no takeover premium and is only marginally above Thursday’s
closing prices of NZ$1.82 (ordinary shares) and 2 NZ$1.80 (preference shares), immediately before Rubicon notified the
Company and the market of its intentions.
Tenon’s new management team is creating value
Already this year, the new management team of Tenon has:
• Achieved agreement for the sale of the company’s forest estate for a price 50% above the implied value attributed to
the forests by the market;
• Returned a significant amount of capital to shareholders (with a further NZ$1.15 per share to come);
• Substantially achieved the previously announced targeted reduction in shared services overheads of NZ$13 million;
• Increased its investment in the high value distribution chain by acquiring a majority shareholding in US-based Empire
Group and a cornerstone shareholding in the European furniture company Zenia House;
• Agreed terms for settling the contractual dispute with major pulp-wood customers, Carter Holt Harvey and Norske Skog,
that related to historical contractual obligations; and
• Announced last Thursday that net profit from continuing activities for the current year was expected to be NZ$32
million, over 50% higher than expectations at the start of the year.
These initiatives have resulted in Tenon’s share price rising by approximately 18% since the start of the year, out
performing the benchmark NZSX50 gross index by over 11%.
Rubicon has not taken account of the latest profit projections
In its Takeover Notice, Rubicon stated that its intended offer is in the middle of the valuation range of NZ$1.75 to
NZ$1.95 per share referred to by Tenon in its letter to shareholders in January 2004 and in a presentation to investors
in March 2004. This valuation range was based on management’s previous profit expectations and does not take into
account the new projections for earnings for the current year. Applying the same calculation used in January and March
to the latest profit forecast gives a valuation range of NZ$2.06 to NZ$2.32 per share.
Rubicon is not offering a takeover premium
Shareholders should expect any bidder to offer a takeover premium to secure control particularly when shareholders are
not being offered the opportunity to exit their entire shareholding but instead to become minority shareholders in a
company controlled by a third party. For example, last week Rural Portfolio Investments offered shareholders in
Wrightsons a 21% premium for a similar partial offer to 3 acquire a 50.01% shareholding. The valuations described in the
previous paragraph do not include any takeover premium.
Shareholders should beware of comparisons to previous share prices
It is also very important for shareholders to note that the impact of the recent capital return and the one-for-two
share consolidation makes it very difficult, and potentially misleading, to compare Tenon’s share price now to earlier
prices.
For example, a shareholder who owned two Tenon shares previously will have received 62.5c in cash for each old Tenon
share and one new Tenon share. This means that Rubicon’s proposed offer of NZ$1.85 for each new Tenon share equates to
an offer of only NZ$1.55 for each old Tenon share, ie. before the capital return and share consolidation.
Shareholders should take no action in relation to the Notice
The Company’s share price has responded positively to the strides made in selling forestry assets, returning surplus
capital and focusing on the more profitable wood products manufacturing, marketing and distribution activities. However,
the Independent Directors believe that the market is yet to fully appreciate the full extent of the value that is being
created in the Company, and its strong growth prospects.
The recommendation of the Independent Directors and the report of the Independent Advisor will be mailed to you on or
within 14 days after the receipt of a formal offer from Rubicon (expected between 22 April and 8 May 2004). In the
meantime, the Company will continue to keep you informed of any significant developments, which will be posted on the
Company’s website www.tenon.co.nz as they become available.
In the interim, we emphasise our strong advice that you do not take any action in relation to the Notice until you
receive the recommendation from the Independent Directors.
Yours sincerely,
Sir Dryden Spring Chairman