18 October 2001 PR158/01
Lawyers join the "Knit Your Own World" Brigade
The report on GM and legal liability released today is just another attempt to re-litigate the Royal Commission's
findings says Federated Farmers President Alistair Polson.
"Like the Greens, one of the report's authors submitted to the Royal Commission, did not like its findings and is now
trying to re-litigate the process.
The Royal Commission considered numerous submissions on legal liability and concluded there was no need to change the
current liability system.
"The Royal Commission recommendations emphasise preventing damage or injury in the first place rather than imposing a
strict liability regime. New Zealand has the best environmental risk management system in the world. Case by case
assessment is a better way of managing risk.
"If GM developers are forced to bear the full financial risk of their activities, New Zealand can expect to loose
research capacity and investment will be diverted offshore, as our comparative and competitive advantage is eroded
irrevocably, said Mr Polson.
"This is reinforced by the Royal Commission's statement that strict liability can be a barrier to innovation and
progress and the weight of international precedent is against setting up such a regime.
"This report gives examples of potential damage claims that could arise from the release GMOs such as personal injury
and effects on non-target species. These types of damage claims are generally not limited to GMOs. Should there be bonds
on all food producers be they conventional, organic of GM?
"Over the past 15 years the EU spent $64 million on 81 research projects to examine the risks involved in genetically
modified crops and products. Not a single study found 'any new risks to human health or the environment, beyond the
usual uncertainties of conventional plant breeding'. Indeed, the use of more precise technology and the greater
regulatory scrutiny probably make them even safer than conventional plants and foods.
"Lets not throw out the baby with the bath water. It is time for all New Zealanders to embrace the cautious use of GM
technology keeping New Zealand's options open to build a strong economy and sustainable environment," concluded Mr
Polson.
ENDS
For more information: Alistair Polson, PH 04 473 7269 or 025 370 085 Catherine
Petrey, PH 04 473 7269.