Data Flash (New Zealand)
Household Labour Force Survey- Q1 2000
Key Points
Headline data overstates the weakness in the Q1 outturn.
Employment fell 0.4% qoq in Q1 following growth of 1.4% qoq in Q4. Average market expectations had been for a rise of
0.5%. Employment rose 1.4% yoy.
The fall in employment was due solely to a 2.4% fall in part-time employment. This followed a rise of 2.8% in Q4.
Full-time employment rose 0.4% qoq and 3.3% yoy. This result was in keeping with recent QSBO surveys pointing to
positive employment intentions.
The fall in employment was driven largely by a decline in the community and personal sector. This sector had recorded
very strong growth in Q4. Strong employment growth was recorded in the wholesale/retail trade sector and, somewhat
surprisingly, in the construction sector.
The number of total hours worked fell 4.4% qoq after rising 4.1% qoq in Q4. The extreme volatility of this data limits
its usefulness as an indicator of economic activity.
The unemployment rate rose marginally to 6.4% from 6.3%. The market and Reserve Bank had expected the employment rate to
fall to 6.1%.
The rise in the unemployment rate was constrained by a fall in the labour market participation rate from a revised 65.5
to 65.3.
Comment
As we suggested following the release of the previous HLFS, the unexpectedly high 1.4% qoq gain in employment in Q4
pointed to a risk of a rather modest increase in Q1/2000. Today's data realised that risk with employment falling 0.3%
qoq. This fall reflects the unwinding of gains made in part-time employment during Q4.
The volatility in part-time employment over recent quarters raises questions about its underlying trend. A further
rebound in part-time employment in Q2 is not beyond the realms off possibility.
In our view a more accurate interpretation of recent trends can be obtained by looking at the Q4 and Q1 outturns
together. This suggests growth in employment of around 0.5%, on average, over the past two quarters.
Focusing on the full-time component of employment leads to a similar conclusion. Continued growth in full-time
employment in Q1 is a sign of positive levels of employer confidence and reflects high levels of capacity utilisation as
a result of extremely strong growth in the second half of 1999.
The RBNZ, in its March forecasts, expected an unemployment rate of 6.1%. The higher rate of unemployment indicated by
today's data implies marginally less pressure on inflation from constraints in the labour market than previously
believed.
However, the labour market still remains tight by recent historical standards. Survey indicators confirm that employers
are increasingly finding it difficult to employee skilled labour. This suggests that the trough in wage growth is likely
to have been reached.
The last cycle showed that wage inflation appears to rise in New Zealand once unemployment falls below 7%. Wage
inflation accelerated to 4% when the unemployment rate last reached 6.0%. Our forecasts see unemployment falling below
6%.
Next week's Q1 Quarterly Employment Survey and Labour Cost Index will provide evidence of the extent to which tight
labour market conditions are beginning to feed into wage growth.
At this stage we estimate that GDP grew by 0.6% in Q1, down from the extreme rates of growth recorded in the second half
of 1999. This translates to 5.2% growth yoy. Next week's retail trade will help us to refine our estimate. The Overseas
Trade Indicies in June will also be important given uncertainty about the price/volume split underpinning recent strong
rates of growth in both exports and imports.
Given growth in employment and hours worked of 1.4% yoy and 0.1% yoy respectively, on the face of it the data suggests
strong productivity growth over the past year. However, as noted, recent part-time employment and hours worked data has
been very volatile. Comparing output growth with growth in full-time employment suggests a more modest rate of growth in
productivity.
We continue to expect the Reserve Bank to raise the Official Cash Rate by 50bps on 17 May. This tightening is necessary
to move monetary conditions closer to a more neutral level. Although recent data confirms our view that growth has
moderated over Q1, indicators of inflation continue to flash red, reflecting growth in commodity prices, the weak NZD,
the closure of the output gap, and growing skill shortages in the labour market. Our forecasts see inflation rising
above 2% later this year and remaining there over the following two years. Such an outcome would not be acceptable to
the RBNZ.
Looking further ahead, there is scope for debate about the timing of further interest rate movements over the remainder
of this year. At this stage we are sticking with our call of a further 50bps hike at the time of the 16 August Monetary
Policy Statement (MPS). However, the possibility remains of a 25bp hike at the 5 July interim OCR review followed by a
25bp hike at the August MPS. Such a path has increasingly been priced into markets in recent days.
Labour Market Data
HLFS (s.a.)::::::::::::::: Employment::::::::::::::: Unemploy.Rate
:::::::::::::::::::: qoq. %:::::::::: ann. %:::::::::::::::
:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
Sep-98:::::::::::::::+0.1::::::::::::::: -0.7::::::::::::::: 7.4
Dec-98:::::::::::::::+0.1::::::::::::::: -0.7::::::::::::::: 7.7
Mar-99:::::::::::::::+1.0::::::::::::::: +0.5::::::::::::::: 7.2
Jun-99:::::::::::::::+0.1::::::::::::::: +1.2::::::::::::::: 7.0
Sep-99:::::::::::::::+0.3::::::::::::::: +1.4::::::::::::::: 6.8
Dec-99:::::::::::::::+1.4::::::::::::::: +2.7::::::::::::::: 6.3
Mar-00:::::::::::::::-0.3::::::::::::::: +1.4::::::::::::::: 6.4
Source: DB Global Markets Research, Statistics NZ
Darren Gibbs, Senior Economist, New Zealand
This, along with an extensive range of other publications, is available on our web site http://research.gm.db.com
In order to read our research you will require the Adobe Acrobat Reader which can be obtained from their website
http://www.adobe.com for free.
For answers to your EMU questions, check Deutsche Bank's EMU web site http://www.db.com/emu or email our helpline
business.emu@db.com.